Moving through my Patron requests for July, this one comes from a user I only know as “cmac”:
Hi Dave, I am a Electrum Club member and I have a request for magical item. I call it the “Gnomish Haymaker” it’s a magic gauntlet that requires attuning by a member of a small race. Here is a 1st attempt on my own but it needs work. I wanted a minor penalty for using it but all I could come up with was disadvantage on attack rolls which slows things down too much…. Attacks deals 1d4 bludgeoning damage plus 1d6 additional force damage in the form of a pressurized air blast. On a hit, you can use your bonus action to force the target to make a DC 15 saving throwing, creatures that are large and above have advantage on the save . On a failure, the target is pushed back 10 feet. In addition, the wielder may use their INT modifier instead of STR modifier for attacks made with this weapon. However, it is unwieldy and. heavy which causes disadvantage on attack rolls. While wearing the gauntlet no other item or weapon can be used in this hand.
Interesting! Let’s break this all down real quick.
- The magic item is a gauntlet called the “Gnomish Haymaker.”
- Only characters of a small race can attune to it.
- The attacks of the weapon deal 1d4 bludgeoning plus 1d6 force damage in the form of a pressurized air blast.
- It can force someone to make a saving throw or be pushed back.
- The weapon can use Intelligence in place of Strength for it.
- Gives disadvantage on attack rolls.
It’s definitely a neat concept, but I fear a little underpowered.
For starters, the weapon deals an average of 6 damage (plus mod) on a hit, 2.5 of which is bludgeoning and 3.5 is force. Granted, it’s magical, but compare it to something like the greatsword which does an average of 7 damage on a hit, and it’s sort of basic. The only thing it has going for it is the force damage which is tough to overcome with resistances and immunities.
Of course, all that is busted open by the disadvantage it deals. Disadvantage will affect its average DPS. Let’s say that the Gnomish Haymaker is pitted against a target that has an AC of 16, and its user gets a +5 to attacks. The user needs an 11 or better to hit AC 16, or a 50% chance. Disadvantage, on the other hand, adds an effective -4.8 penalty to the attack roll, so now the user needs a 16 or better to hit AC 16, or a 25%. The average damage for a user with +3 Intelligence bonus will be 9. So without disadvantage that’s an average of 4.5 damage per round, and with disadvantage that’s an average of 2.25 damage per round.
To put it in perspective, if the user used a mundane dagger with a +3 damage bonus, they would deal more damage. It wouldn’t be magical, and there’s not a chance for pushback, but ultimately we’re talking about a common magic weapon. And since it requires attunement, it’s unlikely anyone will use it, favoring something that packs a little more punch (no pun intended.)
Here’s what I suggest for an uncommon magic item build:
I’ve amped up the damage a bit putting it in the realm of what’s possible with an uncommon magic item. Now, you only get the disadvantage on attack rolls if you use the extra force damage property.
Have a request?
All Patrons get requests on DMDave’s Patreon. Plus, you get PDFs, previews for BroadSword Monthly, and a whole lot more.
Note: couldn’t find the name of the artist for this work. If you know who it is, let me know down in the comments. Thanks!